Which Came First?


CaptureWhich came first – media or ADHD? CcaM researchers Ine Beyens, Jessica Taylor Piotrowski, and Patti Valkenburg sought to answer to this long-standing question. They learned that it is not media use that is predicting attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Instead, ADHD behaviors (i.e., hyperactivity, impulsivity, attention problems) predict children’s (violent) media use.

Parents, health practitioners, and scholars have often expressed concern that children’s screen media use causes ADHD [media effect perspective]. Other scholars, on the other hand, have argued that ADHD behaviors increase the consumption of media, particularly violent media content [media selection perspective]. And yet, empirical work has not comprehensively looked at the potential for either (or both) of these processes. 

To address this so-called "chicken or the egg problem", a team of researchers at CcaM (Beyens, Piotrowski, & Valkenburg) analyzed longitudinal parent-report data of 890 children (aged 4-8 years old). Using a random intercept cross-lagged panel model, Beyens and her colleagues investigated the potential relationships between a child's ADHD-related behaviors and a child's violent media use over a three-year-period

Results support a media selection hypothesis, but not a media effects hypothesis. Specifically, when children experienced more ADHD-related behaviors, they subsequently consumed more violent television programs and games. The reverse was not found. 

10.1177 0093650218782300 fig1

You can access the manuscript via the publisher's website at: To learn more about this research, you can contact the corresponding author - Dr. Ine Beyens - via email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Complete reference: Beyens, I., Piotrowski, J.T., & Valkenburg, P.M. (Online First). Which came first? Assessing transactional relationships between children’s violent media use and ADHD-related behaviors. Communication Research. doi: 10.1177/0093650218782300


Related Articles

News Archive

Congratulations Photo 1
Feb 03, 2017

Congratulations CcaM’ers!

May12017 Each year, communication scholars worldwide gather at the annual meeting of the International Communication Association (ICA) to…
robot aid in therapy
Jan 22, 2017

New PhD Student Joins CcaM

Jan12017 Starting January 2017, Caroline van Straten, a graduate of the Research Master program Artificial Intelligence at Utrecht…
user generated content
Oct 19, 2016

New PhD Student Joins CcaM

Oct202016 CcaM is happy to welcome its newest PhD student, Marthe Möller, to the team. During her studies, Marthe will be working on the…
nao red 300x200
Jul 25, 2016

The Robots are Here!

July102017 It’s official! With the recent arrival of several NAO robots, the team for Professor Jochen Peter’s project “Children and social…

uva university of amsterdam ascor